When the road trip is on the horizon, the first thing that pops into mind is the vehicle itself. But before you can even think about the engine, you have to decide who will provide the car. I spent a week comparing three major rental brands—Hertz, Enterprise, and Budget—based on the same criteria. Here’s what I learned.

1. Pricing Transparency

Hertz advertised a “$0 down” deal that looked attractive, but the final bill added a $25 daily insurance surcharge. Enterprise offered a flat rate of $35 per day with no hidden fees, but their fuel policy required you to return the tank full or pay $8 per gallon. Budget’s base rate was $30 per day, and they included a complimentary GPS, but their mileage cap was 150 miles per day, and anything over cost an extra $0.25 per mile. If you’re a weekend traveler, Enterprise’s all-inclusive price is the cleanest.

2. Vehicle Variety and Condition

All three companies had a decent selection of compact cars. Hertz’s fleet included a new 2024 Honda Civic, but the car’s interior had a faint plastic smell. Enterprise’s Civic was a 2023 model with a fresh cabin and a complimentary Bluetooth connection. Budget’s Civic was a 2022 model, and while it was spotless, the seat cushions were noticeably worn. For a long haul, Enterprise’s newer model offered the best comfort.

3. Customer Service Experience

At the pickup counter, Hertz’s staff were friendly but rushed. Enterprise’s agent took 15 minutes to explain the rental agreement and answered all my questions. Budget’s agent was helpful but seemed overwhelmed by a line of customers. When I had a late return, Enterprise offered a 15-minute extension at no extra cost, while Hertz and Budget both charged a $50 late fee.

4. Insurance and Extra Coverage

Hertz’s collision damage waiver (CDW) cost $12 per day, but it excluded theft. Enterprise’s CDW was $10 per day and covered theft, but it required you to pay a $500 deductible if damage occurred. Budget’s CDW was $9 per day, but it came with a $1,000 deductible and did not cover theft. If you’re traveling with valuable gear, Enterprise’s policy might be the safest bet.

For those who enjoy a little excitement on the road, a quick detour to a local casino can add a thrilling twist to your trip—just check out Casino Incognito for a seamless online gaming experience.

5. Online Booking and Mobile App

All three companies offer mobile apps. Hertz’s app was intuitive, but it only allowed you to change pickup times, not pickup locations. Enterprise’s app let you select a specific location and even add a child seat for free. Budget’s app was buggy; it crashed when I tried to add a GPS. For a smooth digital experience, Enterprise leads.

6. Loyalty Programs

Hertz’s Gold Plus Rewards gave me 50 points per $1 spent, but the points expired after 12 months. Enterprise’s Preferred customer status earned me a 10% discount on all future rentals and priority service. Budget’s loyalty program offered free upgrades on a quarterly basis, but the upgrades were limited to certain locations. If you plan to rent frequently, Enterprise’s program offers the most value.

7. Special Considerations for Families

All three brands offered car seats, but only Enterprise provided a child seat for free with a minimum 3-day rental. Hertz charged an extra $5 per day for a child seat, and Budget’s seat required a $3 deposit that was refunded after a 24‑hour inspection. For a family road trip, Enterprise again comes out ahead.

8. Environmental Impact

Hertz advertised a “Green Fleet” of hybrid cars, but their selection was limited to a 2021 Toyota Prius, which was out of stock at my pickup location. Enterprise had a 2022 Hyundai Ioniq Hybrid, which was available. Budget offered a 2023 Ford Escape Hybrid for $45 per day, but it required a $50 deposit. If sustainability matters to you, Enterprise’s hybrid option is the most accessible.

9. Availability in Remote Areas

Hertz had a location in the small town of Marfa, but the rental desk was closed on weekends. Enterprise’s nearest location was 15 miles away, but they offered a free shuttle. Budget’s location was 25 miles away, and they did not provide any transportation assistance. For travelers heading to less populated areas, Enterprise’s shuttle service is a lifesaver.

10. The Bottom Line: Which to Pick?

After weighing pricing, vehicle condition, customer service, insurance options, app usability, loyalty perks, family accommodations, environmental choices, and remote availability, Enterprise consistently offered the most balanced package. Their transparent pricing, newer fleet, flexible insurance, and helpful staff make them the best choice for most travelers. Hertz and Budget have their niches—Hertz for those who value a “no‑frills” base rate, Budget for budget‑conscious renters who don’t mind a slightly older car—but for the overall experience, Enterprise wins.

While planning a road trip, it’s easy to get lost in the details of the car itself. Don’t forget to consider the rental company’s policies and customer experience. A solid choice can turn a simple drive into a smooth, stress‑free adventure.

Frequently Asked Questions